WHUDeano 11:37 Sun May 12
Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
|
Who is the better player and if you could only pick one, who makes your 11?
|
|
|
Replies - In Chronological Order ( Show Newest Messages First)
SurfaceAgentX2Zero
11:39 Sun May 12
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Antonio. But to be fair, Sincs is 46 now.
|
Takashi Miike
11:42 Sun May 12
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair was a better player, but Michail's had a very good season and looks to be enjoying the game again
|
AKA ERNIE
11:43 Sun May 12
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Antonio by a fucking mile
|
twoleftfeet
11:45 Sun May 12
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Antonio without a shadow of doubt.
|
Iron Duke
11:45 Sun May 12
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair was class. There is really no comparison.
|
Vexed
11:51 Sun May 12
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair is the best at driving while several times over the limit.
|
Eric Hitchmoe
12:01 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair. A truly class player who scored some stunning goals for us, as well as that inch-perfect cross-field pass for that Di Canio goal. Antonio is some player but he is more frustrating than Sincs ever was. That said, he's been phenomenal during the later part of this season.
|
Alex G
12:02 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair. One of my all time favourite hammers. Until the 2002 world cup and it seemed like he stopped trying the season afterwards.
|
Alex Bunbury
12:03 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Antonio was non league standard this time last year by most accounts on here.
|
Pagey
12:07 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair was brilliant for us. Up there with the very best we’ve had in recent years. Antonio has been great for us in the main but there’s no contest.
|
chelmsfordhammer
12:08 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
sinclair
|
El Scorchio
12:12 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair.
I like Antonio, but Sinclair was a better player.
|
BRANDED
12:13 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Love them both
|
Westham67
12:13 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair. Antonio is playing well but he is no Sinclair
|
ATBOG
12:14 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Sinclair was the better player but Michail gets my vote. Doesn’t give up
|
Any Old Iron
12:35 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
I'm a big fan of them both. I thought that Tricky Trev was our best attcking player for a couple of years; way more effective and reliable than Di Canio.
I've always backed Antonio because when he's fit he's strong, pacey, fearless and scores goals. Funny how the many on here who were cunting him off earlier in the season have gone very quiet.
Anyway, as good as Maichail is on his day Trevor was definitely the better player. He had more of a footballing brain which gives him the edge.
|
Texas Iron
12:43 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
ALEX 12.02
Agreed...
Selfish Sinclair...only wanted to play in a position to get and stay in the England team...
To the detriment of WHUFC...
|
Takashi Miike
12:46 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
selfish? he played in various positions and did well, even at times as a wingback when Harry picked three CBs, and never moaned. probably one of the least selfish players I've watched
|
gph
12:50 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
I'll tell you when Antonio's West Ham career is over
|
Pagey
12:58 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
|
Any Old Iron 12:35 Mon May 13
Re: Michail Antonio vs Trevor Sinclair
The reason why many were “cunting Antonio off” earlier in the season was because he was shit.
However, he clearly knuckled down and has started producing what we all know he can. You can’t just take the plaudits when you’re great and get no criticism when you’re not performing.
Antonio’s had plenty of praise lately on here so I’m not sure why you’re saying that everyone has gone very quiet,
|
| 
